Sunday, October 11, 2026

The Palsy We Can't Feel

Fr. Mike Keppler · Job 24:1-17; Ephesians 4:17-32; St. Matthew 9:1-8

Watch the Sermon

Well, good morning again, my fellow encouragers.

I’ve always loved that the 9th chapter of St. Matthew’s gospel begins with a boat and a short crossing home. “AND he entered into a ship, and passed over, and came into his own city.”

This morning’s lesson happens among neighbors, people who knew one another’s names and troubles.

“And, behold, they brought to him a man sick of the palsy, lying on a bed:” We don’t know who “They” are. Scripture isn’t specific, but we can assume “They” were family or friends. At any rate, the man couldn’t walk to Jesus, so “They” did the walking for him.

Then St. Matthew says something that should give us pause. Seeing their faith, Jesus spoke to the sick man. Their faith. Not the man’s faith. Their faith.

The first word of forgiveness in this gospel answers to faith that somebody else carried in on their shoulders. Matthew puts the weight on the carrying, and so should we.

Notice what the narrative doesn’t say: it attaches no fault to this man. It never says he brought the palsy on himself. Many in Jesus’ day thought that way, and some of us carry that fear today; that if the body fails, the soul must have failed first. This gospel doesn’t say that, so hear it without that fear.

Some of you know the weight of the palsied man’s bed. You’ve lifted a husband, a mother, a friend, many times. You’ve driven to the appointments, sat in the waiting rooms, learned the names of the pills.

Perhaps you’ve wondered whether any of that counted with God. This morning’s gospel counts the carrying you’ve done as faith. You are the “They” in the Gospel.

Now, most of you know about my hands. Some of you have seen the braces. Arthritis lives in my hands and wrists, and it keeps one simple rule: if I overdo it, it hurts. I don’t love the rule, but I’ve learned to be grateful for it.

The pain is my hands talking to me. It tells me to stop before I make it worse, and it sends me to Jane, who gets the braces off the dresser and puts the Tylenol in my palm with a glass of water. The pain is what turns her into “Dr. Mom.” She can’t help me with what I don’t feel.

Here’s the thing, though. The Tylenol is a mercy, but it hides a temptation. I can work right past what the joints are saying. The hands go quiet, and quiet isn’t the same as well.

The soreness I didn’t feel at three o’clock is the swelling that keeps me from closing my fist at six. Jane doesn’t give me the Tylenol so I can keep going. She gives it so I can rest.

And that’s St. Paul’s word in chapter four of his epistle to the Ephesians. The Gentiles walk “in the vanity of their mind, having the understanding darkened, being alienated from the life of God through the ignorance that is in them, because of the blindness of their heart: who being past feeling have given themselves over unto lasciviousness.” They are past feeling with a heart that has stopped talking.

St. Chrysostom’s picture of this may help us understand St. Paul’s message more fully. Chrysostom makes this analogy: “a limb so deadened it feels neither the fire nor the knife, where every remedy is wasted until the numbness is lifted.”

In other words, the man who groans over his sin … the one who sees it, who hears it, isn’t the frightening one. He can still be carried. The frightening one is the man who has found a way to stop hearing it as sin. And honestly, some weeks I’m that man. Not in my hands. Somewhere Jane can’t reach with a brace.

And our Old Testament lesson from Job 24 won’t let me stop there. “Why, seeing times are not hidden from the Almighty, do they that know him not see his days?”

Job looks out at the world and sees the poor wet with the mountain showers, hugging the rock because there’s no shelter, and laborers who tread the winepresses and stay thirsty.

Their pain talks all day long, and nobody is listening. Nobody brings them the Tylenol. So carrying the bed has a body and a soul to it. Some of us need the numbness lifted. Some of us need someone to finally hear what our bodies have been saying all along.

So here’s the question. Which of our own hands has gone quiet? And whose pain have we been walking past?

The honest answer might make us leave here today resolved to do better. That’s fine, as we go forth with today’s Collect on our lips. “O GOD, forasmuch as without thee we are not able to please thee; Mercifully grant that thy Holy Spirit may in all things direct and rule our hearts; through Jesus Christ our Lord.”

The first part of that prayer, acknowledging that without God we cannot please Him, is a hard sentence to pray if we’ve spent our lives being the dependable one.

Article XIII gives it its full weight: “WORKS done before the grace of Christ, and the Inspiration of his Spirit, are not pleasant to God, forasmuch as they spring not of faith in Jesus Christ.” That doesn’t make our kindness worthless. It means kindness was never meant to start with us.

So the question was never, “How do I try harder at carrying people?” St. Paul doesn’t say, “make yourselves new.” He says, “Be renewed in the spirit of your mind.” It’s something received, the very thing we asked for in the Collect. He moves the heart before He moves the hands.

And those three small words, “in all things,” leave no corner outside his rule, including the corner where we quietly decide who’s worth carrying: the difficult relative or the neighbor who never says thank you. The Spirit gets a say there too.

Then Paul turns uncomfortably practical. Put away lying and speak truth with your neighbor, for we are members one of another. Be angry and sin not; don’t let the sun go down upon your wrath. Let him that stole steal no more, but labor with his hands, so that he may have something to give to him that needeth.

Each one of those frees up a hand. The liar can’t lift a corner of anybody’s bed, because he’s busy keeping his stories straight. The man nursing his wrath past sundown can’t lift it either, because his arms are full of grievance. And the thief who learns to work finds out his hands were made for giving.

Psalm 72 prays for a King. “1 GIVE the King thy judgments, O God, * and thy righteousness unto the King’s son.” And it tells us what that King does.

“12 For he shall deliver the poor when he crieth; * the needy also, and him that hath no helper. 13 He shall be favourable to the simple and needy, * and shall preserve the souls of the poor”.

That’s the answer to Job. Psalm 72 says there’s a King who notices. And when a parish gives liberally to the poor, as Article XXXVIII asks of us, the people of Job 24 see something of that King’s rule on earth. Not all of it, but something of it.

St. Paul also warns us not to grieve the Holy Spirit: bitterness, wrath, clamor, evil speaking, malice. Resentment makes us too heavy to carry anyone.

So let me be practical too. Make the phone call. Bring the meal. Sit with the one who’s lost all feeling for prayer, and pray for them when they can’t. Somebody in your life is past feeling this morning. You may be the four friends God intends to use.

Let’s go back to Capernaum now. Jesus’ own city. The scribes heard Him forgive this man and said within themselves that he blasphemed. They were right that only God forgives sins. They just didn’t know who stood before them.

So Jesus asks which is easier … to forgive or to heal … and answers by doing the one they can see physically so they’ll believe the one they can’t. “But that ye may know that the Son of man hath power on earth to forgive sins,” He says to the man, “Arise, take up thy bed, and go unto thine house.” And he does.

But don’t miss the order. The forgiveness comes first. “Son, be of good cheer; thy sins be forgiven thee.” All before anyone’s legs work, the deepest palsy got the first word.

St. Matthew says, “But when the multitudes saw it, they marvelled, and glorified God, which had given such power unto men.” Unto men. That’s why the Church dares to speak absolution with a human voice.

When I stand before you after the confession and pronounce absolution, make no mistake: the authority doesn’t belong to me. It’s God’s. I am simply the messenger.

Article XVI of the Articles of Religion won’t let any of us think we’ve fallen too far for absolution. “NOT every deadly sin willingly committed after Baptism is sin against the Holy Ghost, and unpardonable.” By the grace of God, Article XVI goes on to tell us, “we may arise again and amend our lives.” Arise. The same word Jesus spoke over that bed.

And so all our carrying comes to rest here, at this altar. This is where we set down the ones we’ve brought, by name, in our prayers. And this is where we find out we’ve been carried too. It’s a gift long before we pray it.

So come, if you’ve been lifting someone’s bed so long your arms ache, and let him count it as faith.

Come, if your heart has gone quiet and you can’t feel it anymore, and let him lift the numbness.

Come, if your corner of the bed slipped this week, if you let the sun go down on your wrath, and hear him say, “…be of good cheer.”

If the Son of man has power on earth to forgive, then let’s believe Him when he does. And if he says arise, then let’s take up the bed again, and carry one another home.

In the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Ghost. Amen.

Join Us in Person

These sermons come to life in the context of word and sacrament. You are welcome at St. Barnabas any Sunday.